SLA vs. DLP: Differences and Comparison
Learn about the differences between these two 3D printing technologies.
Stereolithography (SLA) and digital light processing (DLP) are two types of 3D printing that build parts by polymerizing a liquid photopolymer resin. SLA employs an ultraviolet laser to trace the shape of each layer. DLP, on the other hand, projects a mask of a whole cross-sectional layer at a time. SLA produces parts with smoother surface resolution whereas DLP can print significantly faster and more cheaply. SLA printing is ideal for applications that need detailed surface resolution.
This article will compare SLA vs. DLP in terms of their differences, materials, and printing technology.
SLA Definition and Comparison to DLP
Stereolithography is a photopolymer-based 3D printing technology. It was first invented by Hideo Kodama in 1980. Six years later, SLS was commercialized and patented by Charles Hull. SLS works by shining a UV laser against a scanning mirror. The mirror directs the laser light in a pattern that traces out the cross-sectional pattern of a single layer of the part. This laser light polymerizes the photosensitive resin wherever it hits a solid surface – either the build platform or the previous layer. After each layer is polymerized, the build platform moves upwards. The part will thus appear to grow out of the liquid.
SLA 3D printers can produce larger parts with more consistently smooth organic surfaces when compared to DLP 3D printers. A typical SLA printer is shown in the image below:
For more information, see our article on What is SLA 3D Printing.
SLA printer.
Image Credit: https://formlabs.com/3d-printers/form-3l/
What Are the Advantages of SLA Compared to DLP?
Listed below are some key advantages of SLA vs. DLP:
- SLA parts have smoother surfaces than those of DLP. This is especially noticeable on curved surfaces.
- SLA printers, in general, can be created with larger build volumes without sacrificing print resolution.
What Are the Disadvantages of SLA Compared to DLP?
Listed below are some key disadvantages of SLA vs. DLP:
- SLA 3D printing machines are typically more expensive than DLP machines.
- SLA machines are slower than DLP machines. This is because SLA traces a single laser across the entire cross-section of the part whereas DLP is able to polymerize an entire layer at once.
FREE SLA 3D Printing Design Guide
DLP Definition and Comparison to SLA
Digital light processing is a photopolymer-based 3D printing technology. It was invented in 1987 by Texas Instruments. DLP projects a UV light onto the build platform to polymerize each part layer. The layer’s cross-section must be masked so only the specified areas get polymerized. This masking is done with a DMD (Digital Micromirror Device) containing thousands of microscopic swiveling mirrors to direct light. They are arranged into a digital pattern for each layer to direct the UV light to the photopolymer or a heat sink below. Alternatively, LED screens can be used as the light source, and the masking is done by simply turning off the LEDs wherever polymerization is not required. The resolution of a DLP 3D printer depends on the resolution of the LED or DMD array as well as the distance from the light source to the polymerization zone. DLP parts comprise cubic volumes called voxels – essentially 3-dimensional pixels. This means any curved edge will look like it was built from many tiny cubes.
DLP 3D printers are cheaper and can print significantly faster than most SLA 3D printers. The image below shows a typical DLP printer:
To learn more, see our guide on What is DLP.
A typical DLP printer.
Image Credit: Shutterstock.com/luchschenF
What Are the Advantages of DLP Compared to SLA?
Listed below are some key advantages of DLP vs. SLA:
- DLP printers can print multiple or large parts faster than SLA. This is due to the fact that the entire print bed can be exposed to the light from the projector. Each layer gets polymerized at once.
- DLP light sources are easier to replace and calibrate. This is in contrast to SLA which often requires the machine to be sent back to the manufacturer for repairs.
What Are Disadvantages of DLP Compared to SLA?
Listed below are some key disadvantages of DLP vs. SLA:
- DLP printers have smaller build volumes. A DLP’s print resolution decreases with distance from the light source. A large build volume means more distance, so if it were too big, the resolution would fall to unacceptable levels.
- DLP cannot produce truly smooth curved faces. Any complex or organic shape will be built from many smaller cubic voxels. This gives the part a pixelated look. However, this is only noticeable upon close inspection.
| Attribute | SLA | DLP |
|---|---|---|
Attribute Print resolution | SLA 25 - 300 microns without voxel pixelation | DLP 25 - 300 microns with voxel pixelation |
Attribute Can print larger parts | SLA Yes | DLP No |
Attribute Wide range of material colors | SLA No | DLP No |
Attribute Minimum feature size | SLA 100 microns | DLP 100 microns |
Attribute Can produce very smooth organic surfaces | SLA Yes | DLP No |
Attribute High-speed printing | SLA No | DLP Yes |
Attribute Has isotropic material properties | SLA Yes | DLP Yes |
Attribute Minimum wall thickness | SLA 0.1 to 0.3 mm | DLP 0.1 to 0.3 mm |
Attribute Parts need support structures | SLA Yes | DLP Yes |
Attribute Largest print volume | SLA 335 x 200 x 300 mm | DLP 192 x 108 x 370 mm |
Table. SLA vs. DLP Comparison
SLA and DLP printers are very similar in terms of performance. The key differences lie in SLA printers’ larger print volumes and better surface resolution.
SLA vs. DLP: Technology Comparison
Both SLA and DLP produce parts by polymerizing a liquid photopolymer resin with a UV light source. Both technologies print parts upside down with the build plate slowly moving out of the resin vat and the part thus appearing to grow out of the photopolymer. DLP 3D printers polymerize an entire layer at a time whereas SLA 3D printers scan the cross-section of each layer using a single focused laser. SLA printers can create smoother parts than DLP printers that tend to have a pixelated type effect on complex surfaces.
SLA vs. DLP: Material Comparison
Both SLA and DLP make use of photopolymers that are cured by a UV light. Variants of these photopolymers are available with either short or long molecular chains. Short chains produce stiffer parts while longer-chain polymers make parts more flexible. Photopolymers need to be cleaned in a solvent bath once they’re finished to remove any uncured resin. A post-curing stage using UV light may also be needed to ensure optimal properties.
SLA vs. DLP: Product Applications Comparison
SLA and DLP can both produce highly accurate parts with very fine features. They’re often used to create casting patterns for jewelry pieces or custom dental molds designed to perfectly replicate a patient's dental structure. If parts are to be used in medical or mechanical applications, they generally need to be post-processed to ensure optimal mechanical properties.
SLA vs. DLP: Print Volume Comparison
SLA printers can be built around larger print volumes. This is because the resolution of the print is not affected by the distance from the light source. The narrow laser cures only a single point worth of photopolymer at any given moment. DLP printers, on the other hand, need to have a relatively shallow resin bath as the resolution degrades with distance. The light source needs to be placed close to the layer to be polymerized. Print volume on DLP printers can be increased with the help of higher resolution light sources but this makes the printer significantly more expensive.
SLA vs. DLP: Surface Finish Comparison
SLA and DLP produce some of the smoothest surface finishes of any 3D printing technology. When compared to each other, SLA prints have better surface finishes, especially on complex curved surfaces. An SLA laser will more closely follow a complex curve. DLP printers, meanwhile, will create curves by approximating them with multiple cubic structures. This results in a pixelated appearance on complex surfaces. The effect is only noticeable upon close inspection and in many cases is not visible to the casual observer.
SLA vs. DLP: Cost Comparison
In general, DLP printers are cheaper than SLA printers. A typical SLA printer can cost $3,750 whereas an entry-level DLP printer can cost as little as $500.
What Are the Mutual Alternatives to the SLA and DLP?
SLA and DLP are excellent 3D printing styles, but there is another alternative technology that can achieve a similar result:
- MJF: Multi-jet fusion is a powder-bed fusion technology. It creates parts by first laying down a thin layer of powder which is heated close to its sintering temperature. Then fusing and detailing agents are placed across the powder in the shape of the part cross-section. Finally, an infrared heat source sinters the treated powder together. This process creates parts with surface finishes that are not as good as SLA or DLP but do come close.
What Are the Similarities Between SLA and DLP?
Listed below are some of the similarities between SLA and DLP:
- Both SLA and DLP can produce parts with very high levels of accuracy.
- SLA and DLP make parts by curing liquid photopolymer materials.
- Printed parts from both styles need to be post-processed via a solvent bath and post-curing under a UV light.
What Are the Other Comparisons for SLA Besides DLP?
Below is another 3D printing technology that is comparable to SLA:
- SLA vs. SLS: Selective laser sintering also makes use of a laser to trace out a part’s cross-section and can achieve excellent resolution. The difference is that an SLS printer uses its laser to thermally fuse thermoplastic particles together instead of the SLA printer’s liquid photopolymer. For more information, see our article on SLS vs. SLA.
What Are the Other Comparisons for DLP Besides SLA?
Below is another 3D printing technology that is comparable to DLP:
- DLP vs. Polyjet: Polyjet printing is an advanced technology that works by spraying a fine layer of photopolymer onto a build plate. A UV light then passes over the liquid to solidify the layer. Successive layers are then deposited on top of one another until the part is complete. Polyjet printers have extremely high resolution. They can print parts in many different materials so they can build different properties and colors into various sections of the same part.
Summary
This article summarized the differences between SLA and DLP 3D printing technologies.
To learn more about SLA vs. DLP and to help select the perfect technology for your products, contact a Xometry representative.
Xometry offers a full range of 3D printing services for your project needs. Visit our Instant Quote Engine to get a free, no-obligation quote in minutes.
Disclaimer
The content appearing on this webpage is for informational purposes only. Xometry makes no representation or warranty of any kind, be it expressed or implied, as to the accuracy, completeness, or validity of the information. Any performance parameters, geometric tolerances, specific design features, quality and types of materials, or processes should not be inferred to represent what will be delivered by third-party suppliers or manufacturers through Xometry’s network. Buyers seeking quotes for parts are responsible for defining the specific requirements for those parts. Please refer to our terms and conditions for more information.